A rejoinder by Etubom Anthony Ani – former minister of finance, 1993-1998
By Henry Boyo
The above question was posed in an article in The Punch Newspaper edition of September 9, 2019, by Columnist, Henry Boyo. I have been a daily reader of Punch for the past 10 years and I have not yet, read any comments from anyone on this question. There is need to discuss this issue, as it appears that there is a massive foreign exchange laundering, going on in our banks. As the architect of the Diaspora Remittances in 1996, I am naturally concerned at the abuses disclosed by Mr. Boyo.”
“When in 1995, we at the Ministry of Finance, reviewed the country’s sources of foreign revenues, we found out that nothing was coming in from Nigerians in the Diaspora, whereas India and Jamaica were living on foreign exchange from its citizens abroad. When I enquired why Western Union and MoneyGram could not receive money from Nigerians abroad, I was told that it was due to our tax laws. As a Chartered Accountant Student in 1962, I studied Comparative Commonwealth Taxation-Nigeria, Jamaica and UK, and I found out that the tax laws of these Countries had the same wordings on imposition of tax (“tax is imposed on income accruing in, derived from or brought into”) the question then to me was why income “brought into” India was not taxed in India. On enquiry, I found that India had modified its tax laws to accommodate its citizens living abroad who wanted to send money in foreign exchange to India. In 1996, I had proposed (and it was accepted by the Federal Executive Council) in a new law, regarding Nigerians repatriating remuneration from abroad, Nigerians repatriating dividends, royalties, fees, commissions from foreign countries receipts by authors, sportsmen/women, musicians, play writers, artist, etc. Such income repatriated into Nigeria in foreign currency was 100 per cent exempted from tax, provided the foreign currency was repatriated through a domiciliary account with a Nigerian bank! With the promulgation of this law, First Bank Nigeria Ltd brought in Western Union in august 1996 while USA brought in MoneyGram a few weeks later.”
“In 1996, Nigerians, abroad, repatriated about $4.5bn (about 50 per cent of our gross revenue from oil) and we ensured that these amounts were brought into Nigeria, intact, in foreign exchange. The receipts increased exponentially in 1997 and 1998 and we also made sure that they were received in Nigeria, in foreign currency. The receipts helped to stabilize our exchange rate mechanism at N82 to a dollar, throughout my tenure as Minister of Finance, to the extent that Naira was internally convertible currency.”
“Some years ago, on my visit to London, I went to Western Union office, at Marble Arch, to test by remitting £500 to my son in Nigeria. I first had to convert the money to dollars and to my surprise; Western Union gave me a quote in Naira to be claimed by my son. I refused their Naira equivalent and insisted that my son mut be paid in dollars. It was obvious to me, that there was anarrangement between our Nigeria Banks and Western Uion/MoneyGram, whereby the former pays from their excss Naira liquidity while the later retains the dollars abroad. In other words, the dollar remittance is retained abroad and is laundered by the Nigerian Banks. This is definitely against the law which provides that all remittances must be brought into Nigeria in foreign currency via domiciliary account.”
“If by chance, as in my case, the dollar is remitted into Nigeria, the Central Bank of Nigeria (CBN) on 14th August 2014 introduced the Outward Money Transfer Service and authorised the same MoneyGram and Western Union to re-export, in tranches of $5000 per transaction, to Nigerians abroad, on payment of the Naira equivalent at the CBN rate of exchange. Thus, Nigeria is the only country in the world re-exporting its remittances. It is relevant to note that the Naira is not a convertible currency but remittances which are meant to stabilize our exchange rates are re-exported! There is something wrong at our Central Bank. It could be that we have imported the mentality of commercial banking into CBN. We now need real Central Bankers to govern our Central Bank. We have Central Bankers amongst those in CBN, and we also have Central Bankers amongst the members of the Nigerian Economic Society (NES) or, alternatively, indeed, we can even go outside Nigeria to employ Central Bankers. The fact is that Diaspora remittances are not retained in Nigeria and there is a collaboration between CBN, Nigerian Banks and Western Union/MoneyGram; in such event, Government must investigate the infraction, punish the money launders, and recover all past Diaspora remittances retained abroad! The Outbound Money Transfer Services must be stopped and all our remittances retained for Naira stability and the Nation’s development.”
POSTSCRIPT OCTOBER 2019: Notably, Chief Anthony Ani, was former Chairman of KPMG (a renowned, International Intervention Accounting Firm), before he became Finance Minister, between 1993 to 1998, under Military rule, led by General Sani Abacha. Arguably, during his tenure, the duo of Tony Ani, an accomplished Accountant, and Professor Sam Aluko, a cerebral Economist, by any standard, formed the nucleus of the engine room of creative policies that stabilized and positively drove Nigeria’s economy, such that, inspite of Nigeria’s International Pariah Status and trade sanctions, in response to Abacha’s iron fist dictatorship, Nigeria’s economy was positively turned around and moved from about 2.0 per cent negative growth in 1993, to minus 0.1 per cent in 1995; thereafter, the economy took a positive trajectory and grew positively by 4.2 per cent in 1996, and stayed steadily, well above 2 per cent until 1999. Similarly, the Naira also remained stable at N82/$ for over 4 years, even when crude oil price was, relatively modest at between $14-22/barrel within the same period.
Furthermore, although Abacha’s Government inherited over 57 per cent Consumer Price Index, in 1993, however, inflation, significantly, dropped to 10 per cent in 1998, and further receded to 6.6 per cent by 1999.
It is probably fair to observe, that the astute economic management which stabilized the Naira between 1994-1998 is certainly elusive today. Sadly, the Naira rate has since plummeted, remarkably, to between N305-360=$, even when crude oil price, (the subsisting mainstay of Government’s annual income) has largely remained above $40/barrel, with an average daily output of about 2million barrels.
Ultimately, the question is, do we have the courage to confront the truth and engage in best practice policies to salvage our economy, or, are we determined to consciously sustain an obtuse strategy that has continuously pauperised our people, when the converse of increasing employment and inclusive growth could have been our portion?