Frank & Fair

July 13, 2019

Cross country grazing in 2019: Sheer barbarism

IPOB bans consumption of beef in South-East

File: Fulani herdsmen turn National Assembly to grazing land in Abuja yesterday. Photo by Gbemiga Olamikan

By Ugoji Egbujo

A man  sets out with cattle and roams from Timbuktu to Calabar, on foot. And that is his life in 2019? He has no shelter. He has no education. He has no healthcare. He lives a wretched and perilous vagrant life. And we say he is entitled to live so dangerously in the name of freedom?

They say the constitution grants him freedom of movement with his goods. But the constitution ought to protect him even from ignorance. The laws should protect him from himself  and his hazardous freedom.  And from the avarice of callous cattle owners. We have signed up to conventions against human and animal cruelty and against slavery. The laws should grant the herdsman human dignity. Cross country grazing is a stone age culture.

This is 2019. We are behind. Our cattle industry should be a goldmine. But we have shackled  our modern selves with the practices of our ancestors who lived in the dark. Modern cattle industry is led by scientists and big businesses, supported by banks.  It’s not a walkabout in the bush with starving cattle. The ranches are scientific projects. The focus is on yield and  cost. Stronger and more prolific breeds. Heavier yields in milk and beef. Nobody in the world grooms cattle for marathons. The industry has no room to sentimental addiction to unproductive, noncompetitive, unhealthy toil or culture.

El-Zakzaky: We will continue our protest all over the country – Shi’ites(Opens in a new browser tab)

A bull with the finest of genes could be worth as much as  three hundred and sixty million naira. Yes, one million dollars. Its sperm cells are fetched and sold at prices higher than diamond.  The bulls and the cows live in ranches. The owners and the herders live in homes on the farms. Their children see their fathers everyday and go to school. The society gives them life. And they are not made feral by perpetual sojourn in treacherous forests.

That is where the industry is in the United States. That is where the industry is in Brazil and India. That is where we should be. We are not in 1850. We can’t exercise and exasperate  ourselves  arguing  legal antiquities, grazing routes and right of way for cattle. We can’t sit astride and let our youths roam the forests with cattle  of very low quality genes, kill themselves and hurt the animals for pretty little.

We must outlaw cross country grazing immediately.

We have outlawed bucket toilets, the shalangas.  Open cross country grazing is another affront to human dignity. We have outlawed riding on motorbikes without helmet.  Open cross country grazing exposes the herders to more dangers than riding without helmets. We have outlawed driving without seat belts. We did it because of public safety. We did it to protect drivers against their own negligence and recklessness. We must outlaw cross country grazing.  We cannot allow herdsmen expose themselves to criminals and cattle rustlers  in the wild  and expose the communities to the rampant  violence that  frictions from open cross country  has begun to bring.

Freedoms can be circumscribed. They are legitimately circumscribed when curtailed  for  reasons of public health and public safety. Intrusions are legitimate if they are the minimum necessary to achieve the stated public aims. A country wide ban on open cross country grazing is legitimate and  long over due. Laws can limit choices, if the  limiting of choices takes away harmful options and improves humanity,  personal and collective autonomy.

A man sets out with his cattle and roams from  Sokoto to Calabar. It’s the culture he knows.  He wanders over 1500 kilometers because he has to feed his cattle. He withers, his cattle shrivels. He is unaware of the other man, his professional colleague in Brazil or India. He has no education. He stoically wades through the perils and makes a pittance for his gruesome labour. The burden of the endless journeys wearies his  cattle drains them  of beef and milk.  It’s slavery.

The other man in Brazil stays  in  his ranch and his cattle leisurely  feed on juicy grasses. They have been called to the same trade. One society is mindful of human dignity and modern trends and has prospered. The other is shortsighted and is stuck to the past. The shortsighted society allows its members to roam free in ignorance. And reaps the harvest of poverty, illiteracy and violence that come with it.

Our cattle industry should be a gold mine. But we must send the herders to school to learn modern animal husbandry. And we must shelter and pamper the animals to better productivity. We must borrow from those who have succeeded their methods and techniques. We stopped child labour. It’s slavery. We established labour laws, to stamp out exploitation and inhumanity. Why then have we let the herders live like wild animals?

Many state governments already have ranches and farm settlements. They should be rehabilitated and put to use. But the soul of a cattle business that will endure  will be private ranches and scientific completion. The federal government can help with sourcing modern breeds and agree extension services.  Let private ranches sprout everywhere.  Let the state governments allocate lands generously to businesses that want them for ranches. Cattle will do well in ranches in Aba and Akure  as they will in Sokoto.

The herders should  be given a life.  It’s 2019.