By Emeka Aginam
President Muhammadu Buhari’s decision to decline assent to the Digital Rights and Freedom has continued to worry promoters of digital rights.
Just last weekend, the coalition of civil society organisations promoting the objectives of digital rights in Nigeria and the rest of Africa has urged President Muhammadu Buhari to review his decision on the Digital Rights and Freedom Bill.
The coalition is made up of Paradigm Initiative, African Academic Network on Internet Policy, Internet Society, Nigerian Chapter, Public and Private Development Centre, Dotunroy.com, Alliance for Affordable Internet – A4AI, World Wide Web Foundation, Senegal ICT Users Association (ASUTIC), Enough is Enough Nigeria (EiE Nigeria)
Jonction Senegal, TechHer NG, and Fantsuam Foundation, Nigeria.
The coalition in a joint statement at the weekend said, “We write to express our disappointment in President Muhammadu Buhari’s decision to decline assent to the Digital Rights and Freedom Bill, which was meant to protect Nigerian Internet users against the infringement of their fundamental freedoms and guarantee human rights online in Nigeria.”
In his explanatory letter to the National Assembly, the President had declined assent to the Bill on the grounds that it covered too many technical subjects.
He also pointed out that some areas covered by the Bill are also covered by ‘various bills pending at the National Assembly’.
The Coalition said, “We, however, believe that these reasons are not valid enough for the President to decline assent to the Bill. The ‘various bills’ as referred to in the letter are still merely Bills which may or may not become laws. For instance, the Data Protection Bill (HB. 02) has been pending at the National Assembly for up to 8 years. Why then would the President miss an opportunity to fill the lacuna for these subject areas when a Bill duly passed by the National Assembly has been presented for assent? We make this assertion with the knowledge that no law or Bill is perfect.
“This is why there exist processes for reviewing laws through repeals and reenactments. It is clear that the Digital Rights and Freedom Bill does not conflict with any existing laws or the Constitution of the Federal Republic of Nigeria, and it is uncommon that a Bill would be stood down because it could conflict with laws that might exist in the future.
“We also cannot overlook the fact that Mr. President did not point out clauses of concern in the Bill as it was done for other Bills against which he had expressed his decision to decline assent. It is important to indicate clauses of concern in order for citizens and observers alike to be aware of such clauses and review as needed. “Our opinion is that the decision not to sign the Bill is nothing short of a missed opportunity for Nigeria to send an important message to the rest of the world on its commitment to protect its citizens from abuse and create a positive regulatory environment for digital technology.
“We, however, note the President’s expression of willingness to review the decision if concerns around the Bill are addressed.
“As a coalition, we hereby assure Nigerians that we will be consulting all relevant stakeholders, including the National Assembly, to review this Bill and carry out the required legislative exercise and submit back to the President in earnest for consideration so that Nigerian citizens can be assured of the Buhari administration’s commitment to safeguarding human rights online in Nigeria”.